Science and Protestantism

Religion in America

Science: a Religious Activity

 Galileo and the Protestants

 Puritans as scientists

 Scottish Common Sense Realism, 1700s

          Reason, nature, Scriptural revelation

                  Evangelical response to Deism

                  Spreads from Presbyterians through colleges

 Baconian empiricism: anti-theoretical

          Bishop William Paley, Natural Theology, 1802

Science Moves Beyond the Bible

 Geology without Genesis

          James Hutton, Theory of the Earth, 1785

          Sir Charles Lyell, Principles of Geology, 1829

 Problem of archeology

          Rosetta Stone, 1822: hieroglyphs & Bible conflict

 “Higher criticism” from Germany

          The Bible as a product of human hands

 Fossils and extinctions: Flood(s)? Evolution?

          Charles Darwin, Origin of Species, 1859

Reconciling science & belief

  Benjamin Silliman, Yale, 1829: “long day”

  The “gap” theory

  William H. Green, 1863, expands Biblical time

  Louis Agassiz, Harvard: creation in geologic time

  Asa Gray, Harvard: divine purpose in Origin of Species

  Liberals, conservatives abandon natural theology

          Liberals: nothing to do with being religious

                  Popularity of theistic evolution: immanence in creation

          Conservatives: science might confirm students’ doubts

                  Popularity of “gap” & “day-age” theories until 1960s

Creationism

  Adventist “flood geology”

           George McCready Price, The New Geology, 1923

  Evangelicals get on board

           “Creationism” reborn: The Genesis Flood, 1961

           “Creation science”

  1990s: the “intelligent design” debate

           Michael Behe, Darwin’s Black Box, 1996

Schools & courts: evolving strategies

  Scopes trial, Dayton, Tennessee, 1925

  The Cold War: the Sputnik crisis, 1957

          Are American kids falling behind in science?

  Supreme Court decisions

          No ban on evolution, 1968

          No creation science, 1987

          No intelligent design, 2005

  New strategy: teach “weaknesses”